This longread was written in collaboration with The Initium《端傳媒》, who has published the Traditional Chinese version. You can become a member of The Initium and support their longform journalism here. I’ve been informed by Substack that this piece might be truncated by Gmail because it exceeds their usual email size — you can click a link when you reach the bottom to read it in its entirety in Gmail, or read it in your web browser. Sorry about this, but it didn’t make sense to me to break a story into two emails!
We sent an email to with a link to finish logging in.